Home / Guides / Hiring help

Hiring help

Junk removal vs dumpster rental vs hauling it yourself: costs and how to choose

Updated November 15, 2026 · 6 min read · MakeClean

Disclosure: MakeClean may earn a commission if you sign up or buy through some links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Commissions never change the prices we quote, and we do not accept payment to rank anything. See our affiliate disclosure.

We have not used any of these services. Prices are quoted from the sources linked, with dates.

Costs side by side

OptionPublished costSource
Junk removal service (they load and haul)National average $138 to $308; low end $80, high end $599Thumbtack junk removal costs (updated Oct 13, 2026)
Dumpster rental (you load)National average $350 to $564, most pay about $442; examples by size: 20 yd $390, 30 yd $401, 40 yd $421. Price depends on size, rental period, filled weight and hazardous items.Thumbtack dumpster rental prices (updated Mar 31, 2026)
Haul it yourself (truck rental)Rental prices vary by location, mileage and dates; no single national price. Dump fees are separate.U-Haul

Junk removal by city (Thumbtack, updated Oct 13, 2026)

CityAverage cost range
New York$199 to $500
Los Angeles$149 to $460
Chicago$150 to $329
Houston$124 to $319
Phoenix$100 to $238
Philadelphia$150 to $400
Dallas$128 to $358
Seattle$130 to $370
Denver$129 to $269
Miami$150 to $398

Source: Thumbtack, which lists these ranges for large US cities. Our cleaning-price pages for the same cities are in the cost by city hub.

How to choose

Two national junk and moving brands, as they describe themselves

Local and independent haulers often cost less or more, so get two or three quotes. Ask what happens to the items (recycling, donation) and whether the quote is binding after the crew sees the load.

Before the truck arrives

Sorting first cuts the pile and the price. Our decluttering checklist walks through room-by-room sorting, and the weekly cleaning schedule helps you keep the space clear afterward.

Get the checklists on paper

The Home Printables Bundle includes the planner, move-out checklist, kids' chore chart, and seasonal checklist — $16, save $8 versus buying them separately.

$16one-time
instant download

Launch offer: use code LAUNCH30 at checkout for 30% off the bundle, until November 30, 2026.

Buy now — $16 See all printables

Secure checkout by Payhip (card or PayPal)

Free: a 15-minute daily reset you can keep on messy weeks

Get the free two-page checklist (US Letter). The daily list plus a simple weekly glance — and a path to the full $7 planner if you want the rest of the system.

Related guides